TheJobsMarket
What Jobs Pay

Pay by Occupation

Short answer

Two people with the same job title routinely earn very different money, and most of the difference is not skill. It is industry, employer size, whether the pay is hourly or salaried, whether a license is required, and where in the distribution they happen to sit. This section is about reading an occupation's range rather than its middle.

An occupation is not a salary. It is a distribution, and the distance from the bottom of it to the top is routinely more than two to one — wider, in most cases, than the gap between the medians of two different occupations.

That means the useful question is almost never "what does this job pay". It is "what moves someone from one end of this range to the other", and the answers are more structural and less about individual merit than most people expect.

What actually moves pay within one occupation

Industry does an enormous amount of it. The same work performed for a hospital, a staffing agency, a school district and a private equity-owned clinic is paid differently, and the gap between industries frequently exceeds the gap between a new starter and a twenty-year veteran inside one of them.

Employer size does more than people credit. Larger employers pay more for the same work, consistently, across almost every occupation measured.

And the structure of the pay matters as much as its level. An occupation paid substantially in commission, tips or piece rates has a base figure that describes almost nobody's actual earnings.

Licenses, credentials and what they are worth

Where a license is legally required, it is a barrier to entry, and barriers to entry show up in pay. Where a credential is merely common, it often shows up much less. Telling those two apart before spending money on one is worth doing.

Ceilings, and who gets past them

Most occupations have a practical ceiling that seniority alone does not break. The people above it have usually changed something other than their tenure — their industry, their specialization, their employer, or the occupation itself. Reading the top of the range as a reward for patience is the most expensive misreading in this section.

Articles in this section

Common questions

Why do two people with the same title earn so differently?

Mostly industry, employer size and pay structure rather than skill. The same work done for different kinds of employer is paid differently, and that gap often exceeds the gap between a new starter and a veteran at one of them.

Does a license increase pay?

Where one is legally required to do the work at all, usually yes, because it restricts supply. Where a credential is merely common or optional, the premium is often much smaller and sometimes not measurable.

Is hourly or salaried better paid?

Neither, inherently. What changes is whether overtime is owed and how predictable earnings are. For occupations with regular overtime, hourly gross can exceed a salaried figure for the same work.

What is a pay ceiling and can I get past it?

The practical top of what an occupation pays in a given industry and place. People who pass it have almost always changed a variable other than tenure u2014 industry, specialization, employer, or occupation.

Do the highest-paying jobs need a degree?

Many of the highest-paying occupations do, but not all, and the ones that do not tend to require a license, a long apprenticeship or substantial risk instead. Entry barriers show up in pay whatever form they take.

Where do commission and tips appear in published figures?

Commissions and production bonuses are included in the published wage figure; tips are reported inconsistently and annual discretionary bonuses are excluded. For those occupations the published number understates total earnings.

Where to go next

Pay by Location

After the occupation, the single biggest factor is where the work is done.

Read it →
CS

Charles Slocs

Data and research

Charles Slocs builds the data side of this site — pulling the federal wage and employment series, matching job titles to occupation codes, and working out what the numbers do and do not support. He writes the pages that are mostly a question about evidence: what a survey measured, how wide the spread really is, and which published figure is out of date.

All articles by Charles Slocs →